Closely-watched GM farm case begins in AustraliaAgence France-Presse . Sydney / New Age Online
An Australian farmer who lost his organic produce licence has taken his neighbour to a court over contamination from his genetically modified canola crop in a closely-watched test case.
Steve Marsh's case against his neighbour Michael Baxter began in Western Australia's Supreme Court on Monday, seeking damages and a permanent injunction to protect his farm from future contamination.
Marsh lost organic certification on 70 percent of his land in 2010 after swathes and seed from Baxter's farm blew onto his property, resulting in "great financial hardship and an uncertain future".
His legal team said the case could set an important precedent.
"As far as we know, this is the first court case of its type anywhere in the world. It will test the legal rights of farmers to choose how and what they farm on their land," said lawyer Mark Walter.
"The case is about freedom of choice, for both farmers and for consumers. It is important that farmers retain their rights to farm GM-free food as this in turn will protect consumers' ability to purchase GM-free food."
Baxter's defence team argues that Marsh's farm, where oats and other grains are grown and sheep graze, cannot be directly affected by the GM canola because he doesn't grow canola himself.
He takes issue with Australia's organic certifying body for what he claims are excessive and unreasonable standards that saw Marsh lose his licence.
The case is being watched closely by Australian legal experts who said there were a number of important issues at stake.
"This sort of liability claim has been long anticipated and expert authors have suggested that it is hard to make a liability claim when at the time a crop was planted the scientific weight of evidence suggests that there was not a reasonable anticipation of harm to others," said Paul Martin, from the Australian Centre for Agriculture and Law at the University of New England.
Martin said the fact that the Australian government's gene technology regulator had ruled that the risks were low fell heavily in Baxter's favour.
Bioethicist Rachel Ankeny, from the University of Adelaide, said both farmers had responsibilities not to harm their neighbours but the case was "far from clear-cut".
"Some might claim that the organic farmer is participating in a certification system primarily to receive a premium price but that system sets unrealistic limits regarding what counts as contamination," she said.
"Others might note that if the canola farmer has taken reasonable care to prevent drift, he may be argued to have fulfilled his ethical obligations."
La Trobe University plant scientist Jim Whelan said the legal battle reflected an ongoing public debate which demonised GM foods and ignored their benefits.
"GM has been shown to have positive effects on the environment, but sadly positive research about GM rarely makes it into the news," he said.
But Rick Roush from Melbourne University dismissed any broader significance of the case because it "has not and would not" occur in the United States or other countries, where "organic certifying agencies allow tolerances for GM presence".
"After more than a billion hectares of GM crops planted since their introduction, how is it that Steve Marsh suing his neighbour can be claimed as a landmark case?"
comments powered by Disqus
The High Court on Tuesday directed the Bangladesh Public Service Commission to publish a fresh preliminary result of the 34th Bangladesh Civil Service exams after including 280 indigenous... Full story
Fifteen eminent personalities have been selected for the Ekushey Padak 2014 in recognition of their contributions to respective fields... Full story
Prime minister Sheikh Hasina on Tuesday expressed the hope that the national flag carrier, Biman Bangladesh Airlines, will be a profit making organisation in the near... Full story
Five academicians of different universities and rights activists on Tuesday sent a legal notice to the home secretary and police to explain in 24 hours the reason of opening fires... Full story
Border Security Force of India Tuesday morning paid 50,000 Indian rupees in compensation to Habibur Rahman for assaulting him physically some... Full story
Environment activists warned Tuesday that farmers of Bangladesh and vegetable exporters may face dire consequences if the government goes along with the Genetically Modified... Full story
Dhaka Reporters Unity will observe a day-long hunger strike programme on March 31, demanding the trial of the murder of journalist couple... Full story
Members of the Bangladesh Coast Guard in a drive rescued 201 people from the Bay of Bengal near Saint Martin's Island Tuesday morning while they were going to Malaysia by two mechanized... Full story
A fire that broke out in a slum in the city’s Mirpur-2 area on Tuesday afternoon burnt over 150 shanties, and 15 shops, witnesses and fire service officials said... Full story
The daylong strike enforced by Progotishil Chhatra Jote, a platform of the left-leaning student organisations, to press for its four-point demand, including stoppage of taking additional fee, began at the social science and arts faculties... Full story
An Australian farmer who lost his organic produce licence has taken his neighbour to a court over contamination from his genetically modified canola crop... Full story
Sixteen people were killed and three others injured when a speeding truck collided head-on with a car on NH-34 at Kaluadighi near Malda town in India... Full story
China and Taiwan will hold their first government-to-government talks Tuesday since they split 65 years ago after a brutal civil war -- a symbolic yet historic move... Full story
Myanmar's national carrier on Tuesday signed a deal to lease 10 Boeing aircraft worth nearly $1 billion that will ply international routes in a bid to tap booming tourism as the once-reclusive... Full story