US regrets over Devyani episodeAgence France-Presse . New Delhi
India on Thursday urged the United States to drop the case against a female diplomat who was arrested and strip-searched and apologise for her ‘terrible’ treatment, ratcheting up pressure in the blistering diplomatic row.
The US secretary of state, John Kerry, expressed ‘regret’ over the episode in New York, and India’s foreign minister Salman Khurshid said he hoped the ‘valuable relationship’ with Washington would soon return to an even keel.
But in a sign of the bruised pride and humiliation felt in India, Khurshid reiterated calls for the visa fraud case against the diplomat to be withdrawn and branded her treatment as ‘terrible’.
‘We have asked for the case to be dropped and withdrawn ... we are not convinced that there are legitimate grounds for pursuing it,’ Khurshid told foreign journalists.
‘I cannot believe if a US senator was arrested he would be put through this
behaviour....I would rather not prejudge. Let us allow the American government to respond.’
Kerry tried to end the row in a phone call to India’s national security adviser on Wednesday, expressing regret and stressing concern that the issue not be allowed to hurt a ‘vital relationship.’
But parliamentary affairs minister Kamal Nath said ‘a mere regret won’t make us happy. They must offer a clear apology and accept that they made a mistake, that is what we will be satisfied with.’
The row was sparked by last Thursday’s arrest of Devyani Khobragade, India’s deputy consul general at its mission in New York, as she dropped her children off at school.
The 39-year-old, who is now free on bail, was detained over allegations that she paid an Indian domestic worker in New York a fraction of the minimum wage and lied about the employee’s salary in a visa application.
Subsequent revelations that she was strip-searched have caused outrage in India and prompted a series of reprisals, including the removal of protective barricades outside the American embassy.
Khurshid confirmed India was transferring Khobragade to its UN mission in New York to secure her full diplomatic immunity, instead of the partial immunity she currently has.
However such a move could prove complicated as any change of designation requires the US State Department’s approval.
In an email to colleagues published Wednesday, Khobragade wrote that she was repeatedly strip-searched and then subjected to a cavity search.
However Preet Bharara, the US federal prosecutor handling her case, has insisted Khobragade was arrested in the ‘most discreet’ way possible, was not handcuffed and was ‘fully searched’ by a female deputy marshal in private as part of standard procedure.
In an interview with Indian television, Khurshid acknowledged there was ‘a sense of hurt’ over the treatment of the diplomat at a time when the Obama administration is looking to bolster ties with New Delhi.
‘Things happen between friends, even things that are terrible,’ he told the CNN-IBN network.
‘My duty is not to allow anyone to damage relations, the relationship,’ he also told reporters. ‘We hope it will return (to normalcy) very soon.’
The diplomat’s father pressed for his daughter’s release, saying he would go on hunger strike if action was not taken.
‘No compensation is enough. We are not beggars,’ Uttam Khobragade added.
The US State Department said it was ‘particularly important to Kerry that foreign diplomats serving in the United States are accorded respect and dignity just as we expect our own diplomats should receive overseas’.
Bharara insisted his sole motivation was to uphold the rule of law, protect victims and hold accountable anyone who breaks the law ‘no matter how powerful, rich or connected they are’.
But India’s foreign ministry spokesman lashed out at Bharara’s comments, saying ‘there is only one victim in this case (and) that victim is Devyani Khobragade’.
The worker is said to have been paid just $3.31 an hour — well below New York’s required $7.25 – despite signing a contract to pay her three times that amount for childcare and other services.
Such wages however are well above the average in India.
The dispute is the second between India and a major Western nation this year.
India reacted furiously in March when Italy reneged on a promise to fly two marines back to New Delhi to face trial over a fatal shooting.
The marines did eventually return after India ordered immigration authorities to prevent Italy’s ambassador from leaving the country.
With a general election just months away, the ruling Congress and the nationalist opposition Bharatiya Janata Party are both keen to demonstrate willingness to take a tough diplomatic line.
Yashwant Sinha, a former BJP foreign minister, has said that India should now arrest the same-sex partners of US diplomats after a court ruling last week that upheld a colonial-era ban on homosexuality.
comments powered by Disqus
Bangladesh has finalized a deal to buy two submarines from China, officials said. The ships would strengthen the Bangladesh Navy protecting the countryÃ¢€™s resources in the Bay, they said. Full story
The banned Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan has threatened to attack Bangladesh high commission in Islamabad following the execution of Jamaat-e-Islami leader Abdul Quader Molla on war crime charges, PakistanÃ¢€™s... Full story
The p[rime minister, Sheikh Hasina, on Thursday said that the leader of the opposition in the parliament, Khaleda Zia, had missed the 10th parliamentary elections but hinted at mid-term polls for the 11th parliament if any understanding... Full story
Young children are at risk of serious health problems from toxic materials found in toys widely available in the capital city. A recent study, undertaken by the Environment and Social Development Organisation, identified... Full story
The US Senate Committee on Foreign Relations has expressed grave concerns over the political deadlock in Bangladesh after a meeting on Wednesday to discuss a resolution on it. The resolution stressed the... Full story
At least 20 activists of Ganajagaran Mancha were injured as police broke up a procession foiling their attempt to approach the Pakistan high commission at Gulshan in the capital on Thursday afternoon. Full story
The Arbitral Tribunal constituted in the matter of the Bay of Bengal maritime boundary arbitration between Bangladesh and India concluded its hearing on the merits from December 9 to 18 at the Peace Palace in The Hague. Full story
Army personnel were moving in various places, setting up camps in district headquarters on Thursday. Officials said that many units of the army started Ã¢€˜reconnaissanceÃ¢€™ in different parts as part of their winter exercise. Full story
The information minister, Hasanul Haq Inu, on Thursday said that the discussion between the ruling Awami League and the main opposition Bangladesh Nationalist Party for a political negotiation had been suspended. Full story
India on Thursday urged the United States to drop the case against a female diplomat who was arrested and strip-searched and apologise for her Ã¢€˜terribleÃ¢€™ treatment, ratcheting up pressure in the blistering diplomatic row. Full story
The anti-corruption watchdog is unwilling at this moment to launch probe into an unusual surge in incomes of a number of leading ministers of the Awami League-led government who are going to contest the January 5 general elections. Full story
The West Bengal chief minister, Mamata Banerjee, has threatened she will never allow the Land Boundary Agreement with Bangladesh to be implemented. Ã¢€˜We are not accepting, not accepting and not accepting... Full story
The expelled Jaitya Party presidium member Kazi Zafar on Thursday said that the country was headed towards a Ã¢€˜civil warÃ¢€™ because of the current volatile political situation. Two Jatiya Party leaders, who... Full story
The four separate committees formed to investigate the fire in the garment factory of Standard Group at Konabari in Gazipur have been allowed time to submit their reports after they missed the deadlines to do so. Full story
President Abdul Hamid on Thursday said Bangladesh policies have helped improving the regional security situation to a great extent in the last five years. Ã¢€˜In the last five years, this region has seen... Full story
Growers started planting seasonal boro rice amid short supply of fertilizer and diesel due to ongoing blockade enforced by the BNP-led opposition alliance, according officials and growersÃ¢€™ leaders. The production cost of boro, the... Full story
Customs officials and Armed Police Battalion arrested a man in possession of a gold bar and 149 gold chains worth about Tk 42 lakh at Hazrat Shahjalal International Airport early Thursday, police said. The arrested, Jamal Hossain... Full story
The government has again extended the deadline for submission of tender for the main works of the proposed Padma Multipurpose Bridge. The new deadline has been fixed on January 9, according to a notification by the Bridge Authority, the main... Full story
The police recovered the body of a housewife from her house in the capitalÃ¢€™s Monipara under Mirpur police station on Thursday morning. The deceased was identified as Sharmin Morshed Maha, 29, wife of Morshed... Full story
Attorney General Mahbubey Alam on Thursday termed the last minute appeal from UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay to halt Abdul Quader MollaÃ¢€™s execution as Ã¢€˜uncalled for and unwarrantedÃ¢€™ The UN High Commissioner... Full story