IndiaÃ¢€™s top court makes gay sex illegal againReuters . New Delhi
India’s Supreme Court on Wednesday threw out a 2009 ruling by a lower court that had decriminalised gay sex, in a major setback for the cause of gay rights in the world’s largest democracy.
The top court stated that only India’s parliament could change the law, by deleting a section of the penal code dating back to the 19th century, thus ruling that the Delhi High Court had overstepped its powers with its decision four years ago.
The move shocked gay rights activists, who had expected the court simply to rubber-stamp the earlier ruling. In recent years, India’s Supreme Court has made progressive rulings on several rights issues.
‘We see this as a betrayal of the very people the court is meant to defend and protect,’ said Arvind Narayan, one of the lawyers representing the consortium of gay rights groups that was defending the 2009 judgment.
‘In our understanding, the Supreme Court has always sided with those who have no rights.’
Section 377 of India’s penal code bans ‘sex against the order of nature’, which is widely interpreted to mean homosexual sex, and can be punished with up to 10 years in jail. The rule dates back to the days of British colonial rule in India.
‘One would never expect the Supreme Court of India to make such a retrograde order, that is so against the trend internationally,’ said rights lawyer Colin Gonsalves.
‘This takes us back to the dark ages. This is a day of mourning for us in India.’
India’s law minister Kapil Sibal said he could not comment on the judgment and did not say if the government planned to seek an amendment to the law.
But it seems unlikely the government will risk taking a stand on the issue in the short term. General elections are coming up in May in largely socially conservative India, and the Hindu nationalist opposition is already gathering momentum.
comments powered by Disqus
Nelson MandelaÃ¢€™s tearful widow was among scores of mourners who paid their last respects before his open casket Wednesday, as the much-loved leader lay in state. Graca Machel, clad in a black head-dress with her eyes shielded by sunglasses... Full story
The Obama administration and Congress clashed on Tuesday over the historic nuclear deal with Iran, exposing deep rifts over a US pledge to refrain from any new sanctions over the next six months in exchange for concessions on enriching uranium. Full story
Rights group Amnesty International has urged Australia to review its asylum seeker policies and end offshore detention after finding Ã¢€˜debilitating and humiliating conditionsÃ¢€™ at processing centres that breach obligations under international law. Full story
MyanmarÃ¢€™s president has pardoned 44 political prisoners, coinciding with the countryÃ¢€™s hosting of the Southeast Asian Games. The majority of those freed Wednesday were activists charged under a peaceful assembly law... Full story
IndiaÃ¢€™s Supreme Court on Wednesday threw out a 2009 ruling by a lower court that had decriminalised gay sex, in a major setback for the cause of gay rights in the worldÃ¢€™s largest democracy. The top court stated that only IndiaÃ¢€™s parliament could change... Full story
PakistanÃ¢€™s chief justice has stepped down after a high-profile career during which he was praised for protecting democracy but also criticised for judicial overreach. Iftikhar Chaudhry marked the end of his term on Wednesday with a speech at the Supreme... Full story
A car bomb went off Wednesday near a gate used by NATO troops in the northern section of the Kabul airport, the Afghan interior ministry said. The Taliban claimed responsibility for the pre-dawn bombing, which caused no casualties. Full story
Gulf states called on Wednesday for the withdrawal of Ã¢€˜all foreign forcesÃ¢€™ from Syria, where Iran-backed Shia militias from Iraq and Lebanon are supporting regime troops against Sunni-led rebels and foreign fighters. Full story
An overnight fire at a farmersÃ¢€™ market in the southern Chinese city of Shenzhen killed at least 16 people and injured five others, local authorities said Wednesday. The Shenzhen municipal government said in a statement... Full story
The national director of the Deaf Federation of South Africa says a man who provided sign language interpretation on stage for Nelson MandelaÃ¢€™s memorial service, attended by scores of heads of state, was a Ã¢€˜fake.Ã¢€™ Asked... Full story
Time magazine on Wednesday named Pope Francis its person of the year, saying that in nine months in office the head of the Catholic Church had become a new voice of conscience. Full story